Forum › Food & Appetite

What do you snack on when you’re just craving something?

37 replies29 peopleOct 21, 2026☆ Follow
Summary

What snacks do people reach for when they feel like eating but aren't actually hungry?

Forum users list a range of low-calorie and higher-protein options they keep on hand for casual cravings. Common choices include yogurt, cottage cheese, pickles, jerky, fresh fruit or vegetables, and occasional treats like dark chocolate or popcorn. A few participants note that cravings often stem from stress or boredom rather than hunger and describe trying to sit with the feeling or choosing protein and fat instead. One user reports that medication eliminated the urge to snack entirely.

What this discussion establishesWhere people disagree

Whether to eat a small approved snack or to sit with the discomfort and examine the trigger instead.

Still open

How to reliably distract from or resolve non-hunger cravings once they are recognized.

Nothing here is advice.

37 replies · 29 people
WarmAnchor39archiveopening post2d

Sometimes I'm not even hungry but still feel like having a little something. I usually reach for Greek yogurt or nuts in those moments. What snacks do you go for?

SharpCinder28archive2d

Pickles are my favorite because they are low in calories. I also like sharing an apple with the dogs along with blueberries. When I eat more starch I cut back on fruit and choose corn on the cob or sweet potatoes without butter instead. For something higher in calories I grab a 26 g protein drink. High-fiber cereal with almond milk works too and pairs well with berries the same way yogurt, cottage cheese, chia pudding, or oatmeal does.

I eat a mandarin because they are in season right now. It is about 40 calories plus vitamin C and roughly 2 g of fiber. If I am still under my daily calories I add some walnuts even though they are calorie dense at about 200 calories for 30 g.

RustTimber42archive1d

I usually grab a carrot. By the time I am halfway through I feel satisfied and they taste fine plain. No prep needed, they are lightly hydrating, and they cool you down if they have been in the fridge on a hot day.

LevelWillow41archive1d

I keep beef jerky within reach at all times. A few saltine crackers with peanut butter can hit the spot too. Depending on what looks good I will finish a bowl of cherries, an apple, or a pear.

BlueFenwick48archive1d

Jell-O, cottage cheese, a smoothie that also gives me something to do, a couple tablespoons of crunchy cookie butter, yogurt, oatmeal, pickles or pickled okra lately, and a couple of stuffed olives.

RustTimber42archive1d

I appreciate you changing your profile picture from that creature you had before.

SharpLedger72archive1d

Greek yogurt, cottage cheese, chicken breast, or a glass of milk.

Something sweet like a small piece of dark chocolate or something salty like a pickle, olives, nuts, or pumpkin seeds. It helps to have a planned treat ready so you do not end up making a big run to the store. I also keep a small bag of potato chips hidden for emergencies and write the purchase date on it. Seeing an old date motivates me to pick a pickle instead. I have heard of people turning protein shakes into ice cream but have not tried it.

ClearTimber11archive1d

Homemade beef jerky, biltong, or store-bought cheese.

NorthWillow72archive1d

In summer I like watermelon, frozen grapes, and carrots. Year round I enjoy boiled eggs with a little mustard, yogurt mixed with granola, different kinds of mixed nuts, and celery with pimento cheese.

RustBramble70archive1d

Yogurt, usually zero percent fat with no added sugar, sometimes flavored, and I add blueberries now and then. A couple tablespoons of peanut butter that contains only peanuts. Cottage cheese.

GreyLedger42archive1d

I found protein puffs in different flavors. They are not exactly like cheese puffs but they satisfy the urge to snack while adding protein and they have a good protein-to-calorie ratio.

IronKettle44archive1d
↳ replying to @RustTimber42

Your Greek yogurt idea is spot on, especially with sugar-free cheesecake flavoring.

RustMeadow90archive1d

I want something different most of the time but lately it has been jerky, protein chips, or a slice of ham and cheese.

RustTimber42archive1d
↳ replying to @IronKettle44

I love it. High protein, low calorie, tastes good, and it works well in a bowl with granola or as a flavor boost in a shake. I mix a batch in a large bowl with a lid and finish it over a week. The texture changes over that time and by the end the pudding mix is fully dissolved. Waiting a day after mixing is probably best but I never do.

Apples are one of the longest lasting options for filling the gap. They are low in calories and come in many varieties. A hand slicer lets you cut one into eight pieces instantly.

NorthWillow72archive1d
↳ replying to @PatientHarbour28

I do like my apples and sometimes add peanut butter.

WrySparrow92archive1d

An individual bag of skinny pop when I want something salty. A frozen yogurt bar when I want something sweet. Some nights both.

RustSignal28archive1d

Cottage cheese. It is always cottage cheese.

ClearWillow37archive1d

Try sitting with the discomfort and learning to tell it apart from real hunger because it will pass. You can still gain weight from healthy foods. I have been active for years but kept grabbing just a spoonful of plain Greek yogurt, an apple, a few berries, or six almonds when stressed and ended up 25 pounds heavier. Now I ask myself if I am truly hungry and if not what triggered it or what I am trying to avoid. Cravings are often a quick dopamine hit rather than hunger. If you do eat, choose meat or fat such as a chicken drumstick, leftover steak, or aged cheese.

GreyLantern71archive1d

Protein bars or shakes, peanut butter on toast, and zero sugar cola.

GreyLantern71archive1d
↳ replying to @ClearWillow37

After spotting that the urge isn't genuine appetite, I get stuck on what follows next. Finding something to pull my attention elsewhere feels like the real puzzle.

GreyHarbour55archive1d

Yogurt, cottage cheese, hard boiled eggs, or eggs over medium with toasted rye and butter. I crave eggs a lot.

ClearWillow37archive1d
↳ replying to @GreyLantern71

I always end up finishing whatever job I'm putting off.

AmberCinder18archive1d

A tiny piece of dark chocolate covered mango, ginger chews that I keep in the house at all times, freeze dried yogurt drops, beef jerky, or a handful of nuts and seeds.

SharpCinder28archive1d
↳ replying to @AmberCinder18

Oh wow. Almost worth the parking lot hassle and the impulse buying that follows.

RustLantern55archive1d

I love freeze dried chocolate covered strawberries, popcorn chips, popcorn from the machine, blue corn tortilla chips with guacamole in the single serve tubs, or mentos.

LevelAlder29archive1d
↳ replying to @ClearTimber11

Biltong! I cannot see or eat it without exclaiming. I need to order some now. Kettle corn popcorn chips for a sweet crunchy option. String cheese is another favorite. Sunflower seeds too. For a treat, ice cream bars that are only 180 calories and taste really good.

SlowLedger99archive1d
↳ replying to @LevelAlder29

I really wish high priestess for dried meats was already a forum title by now.

↳ replying to @RustTimber42

Now I want to see that creature. I never got the chance.

I snack on turkey deli meat. I keep it stocked because I am a sucker for it and it gives me protein too.

PatientPebble79archive21h
↳ replying to @GreyLantern71

That is the real question. Knowing it is not real hunger and then what to do is what these medications ideally address by reducing the food noise in the first place.

IronKettle44archive14h
↳ replying to @RustTimber42

Totally, buddy! Mixed about a quarter package into cottage cheese plus plain yogurt, and it came out super dense right away, in that trendy slang folks use now. Thinking of prepping batches ahead and letting them rest awhile. Gonna experiment with the idea. Thanks once more!

IronKettle95archive13h

I am apparently unusual. Since my first shot I have eaten zero snacks. The medication removed any desire to snack and I am grateful. I do one meal a day and have never cheated. My issues were portion control and late night snacks and both were fixed right away, making the routine simple to follow.

Related discussions

Add your experience

If you have tried it, this topic is still open. Sign in to reply — it takes a minute.