CommunityFood & Appetite

Carb-Fat-Protein %'s and tracking

4 replies5 peopleMar 11, 2026☆ Follow
Summary

What macro percentages and daily calorie deficits are people using while tracking intake on weight loss plans?

Participants report a range of macro splits from 50/30/20 carb/fat/protein up to much higher protein emphasis around 40-50% of calories. Most avoid strict daily perfection and instead watch weekly weight trends or scans for progress, noting that protein helps with hunger even when on medication. Practical intakes often fall short of protein targets, and calorie deficits are described as hard to pin down precisely due to tracking errors.

What this discussion establishesWhere people disagree

Whether to prioritize exact daily macro percentages versus minimums and maximums with flexibility

Still open

What consistent calorie deficit most people actually target each day

Nothing here is advice.

4 replies · 5 people
SlowLantern46archiveopening postMar 11

Hello. If people are tracking, what carb fat and protein percentages do they use? I log with an app and currently run 50 percent carbs, 30 percent fat and 20 percent protein while trying to hit one gram of protein per pound of my goal weight, which feels tough. I have not started the medication yet and am still looking into it. Should these ratios be changed or do they seem fine? Also, what daily calorie deficit are most aiming for, though I know it varies.

LevelThistle44archiveMar 11

I set daily minimums for macros and a maximum for calories but do not worry much beyond those. Protein often falls while traveling and I skip tracking then unless it is simple. Longer averages matter more than single day numbers. Deficits are tough to figure accurately because of errors in logging food, exercise and daily movement. Weekly scale numbers and the seven day average trend, plus body scans, show what is really happening.

AmberSignal47archiveMar 11

What is the goal weight being used? If it is two hundred pounds then one gram of protein per pound means two hundred grams and eight hundred calories from protein alone. Adding the other macros at the stated ratios would total four thousand calories, which would lead to gaining rather than losing. The split I follow for fat loss is forty percent protein, forty percent carbs and twenty percent fat by calories, which works out to roughly two hundred grams protein, two hundred grams carbs and forty five grams fat. In practice protein lands around one hundred fifty grams on average while carbs stay near two hundred and fat a little higher, keeping total intake under two thousand calories most days.

BlueAnchor24archiveApr 28
↳ replying to @SlowLantern46 (opening post)

Reaching the protein target is really difficult for me as well.

CopperSignal27archiveApr 28

I ran my usual daily food intake through an AI tool to break down the calories, carbs, protein, fat, fodmap and fibre. Because I keep meals mostly consistent to avoid gut issues the numbers are probably reliable. It came back around forty to fifty percent protein, often near fifty, ten to twenty percent fat around fifteen, and thirty to forty percent carbs near thirty five. The very high protein approach started when dropping from one hundred forty five kilos to seventy five before the newer medications were available, and I kept it because it worked. Even with fifteen milligrams of one medication plus five of another plus point five of a third my body still acts like it needs far more food to avoid starvation, so the protein keeps me from feeling constantly hungry.

Related discussions

Add your experience

If you have tried it, this topic is still open. Sign in to reply — it takes a minute.