Forum › Food & Appetite

Favorite Greek yogurt brand?

52 replies24 peopleNov 3, 2026☆ Follow
Summary

What Greek yogurt brands do people like best and why?

Users share personal favorites for taste and texture, with many preferring full-fat plain versions over flavored ones. Several describe making their own at home using a starter and whole milk for better control. Availability varies by location, leading some to rely on warehouse clubs or local stores while others experiment with mix-ins like protein powder or berries.

What this discussion establishesWhere people disagree

Whether commercial Greek yogurt can match traditional or homemade quality, with some viewing supermarket versions as overly processed

Still open

Which option works best for people without access to specialty stores or who want the absolute thickest texture

Nothing here is advice.

52 replies · 24 people · page 1 of 2
GreyLantern71archiveopening post6d

What’s your favorite brand of Greek yogurt? Mine is the thick style one. The store brand is good too. Recently tried the plain version from another popular maker and was surprised it was watery.

SlowAlder33archive6d

This one really excels when it comes to purity. I find the higher fat version especially smooth in texture. When looking for a fast meal with both protein and fat I stir in a few scoops of powder. The honey flavored choice from the other brand falls short on cleanliness but still delivers great flavor. It comes close to those older custardy styles that came with the shiny tops.

This yogurt is incredible. It's better than any other I've tasted before. I adore it. My preference is always for the full-fat kind. Yet the places I usually shop at don't have it available. I tend to go for yogurt that has no added flavors. Those with flavors contain sugar and that's something I don't want. From a warehouse club I pick up some inexpensive yogurt. The taste by itself is not something I enjoy. Therefore I stir in a portion of vanilla protein powder. This powder is high quality and has no sugar in it. The mixture tastes much better this way. It ranks as one of my most liked meals.

I like the no sugar added version from that popular brand. Toss in some berries and you're good to go.

SharpCinder28archive6d
↳ replying to @ClearLantern70

Something similar to the thick style one to me is the whole-fat Greek yogurt from another chain. And only a few dollars.

↳ replying to @SharpCinder28

That chain is no where near me either... other local stores or the warehouse club. Washington state is beautiful but sad at the same time....

SlowAlder33archive6d
↳ replying to @SlowAlder33

Actually I enjoy those two options too but what I truly prefer is yogurt I've prepared myself at home. I usually produce two batches every week. I pick up a small container of yogurt with either two or five percent fat plus a full gallon of whole milk. I empty the milk into my appliance and select the heating cycle for yogurt. Once it cools I stir in the small container using a spatula. I then choose the sixteen hour yogurt cycle and return later to a large amount of finished yogurt. At that stage I sometimes strain away the liquid if I prefer a thicker texture.

GreyLantern71archive6d
↳ replying to @SlowAlder33

Which taste option for the shake mix are you picking? That honey yogurt variety seems appealing. I really enjoy that thick style. It's smooth and yummy. Might give the plain flavored mix a shot.

GreyLantern71archive6d
↳ replying to @PatientCompass47

What berries do you like? No stores from that chain near me either. Seems like a really unique store.

GreyLantern71archive6d
↳ replying to @SlowAlder33

That's amazing that you create yogurt yourself. Is it possible to put portions in the freezer?

GreyLantern71archive6d
↳ replying to @SharpCinder28

So jealous you have a store from that chain!

IronFenwick84archive6d

I read somewhere that one discount chain is the sister store to another popular one.

↳ replying to @GreyLantern71

Blueberries dominate in most batches while strawberry shows up only occasionally. The yogurt turns out to be quite a bargain from the store.

SharpCinder28archive6d
↳ replying to @GreyLantern71

I used to feel envious of everyone else, right up until a new spot showed up nearby a few weeks back.

↳ replying to @SharpCinder28

Seems like you're trying to make us beg for your thoughts on it.......goodness, fine...."hey there....what about that market..?" ....now speak!....

The only yogurt I currently buy or know of is the high protein ones from that brand...not unsurprisingly, I buy it because it has, wait for it....high protein....tastes fine too..... 👍

SlowAlder33archive6d
↳ replying to @GreyLantern71

I get my own mixed formulas prepared to my liking and tend to purchase quite a lot with each order. They suit me perfectly. I could set some aside in the freezer but go through it rapidly enough that there's no need. I have noticed others who store theirs for longer though, either as big frozen blocks or shaped cold treats.

BlueLantern77archive6d

I always stock up on multiple large containers of that yogurt at the warehouse whenever I shop there because it lasts nearly two months before expiring and works out cheaper by weight than the other brand.

↳ replying to @GreyLantern71 (opening post)

The big box store has a house brand. I love their full-fat Greek.

High protein for moderate calories is amazing macros.

↳ replying to @IronFenwick84

Interesting. I love that other popular chain.

LevelTimber64archive6d
↳ replying to @IronFenwick84

100% true. But do y'all have another discount chain nearby? That's some sweet shopping. ETA: favorite yogurt is the non-fat plain version of the thick style one. 2nd place is the high protein one from the popular brand. Do not buy the protein focused yogurt from that other line. It's not yogurt at all.

AmberWillow13archive6d

I'm unsure if many folks shop near one of those stores, yet the greek yogurt with fruit layering at the bottom appeals to me. Strawberry happens to be my regular pick, and blueberry works nicely too. It may lack the micros of alternatives, but I keep choosing what suits my taste. I stir in a teaspoon of chia seeds to boost the fiber.

SharpCinder28archive6d
↳ replying to @AmberWillow13

Cool. And the cashback app has like 10 percent off for our local store here.

NorthWillow72archive6d

I should give the twenty gram version a shot since coconut is my favorite taste. The ones I buy always come out dense rather than thin, perhaps fortune has been on my side. The taste pairs nicely when I add small pieces of coconut. Because of suggestions from the local expert on nutrition, kefir has entered my shopping list now. It has a good flavor and supposedly offers major advantages for digestion.

Currently I only eat one specific yogurt and really enjoy it. Each day I have two servings mixed together with the chia pudding containing protein that I whip up myself at home and this gives me my perfect fiber plus protein pairing.

WarmSparrow60archive6d

For more than fifteen months I've had one every other day. I put strawberries and blueberries on top along with walnuts and pecans. This is the meal I look forward to most.

AmberAnchor57archive5d

Zero percent version of the thick style one for me with a teaspoon of premium jam mixed through it .delicious

The light version from that big brand by a mile for flavor and variety. Moderate protein and low calories. They can be beat on protein but not flavor.

KeenThistle22archive5d
↳ replying to @GreyLantern71 (opening post)

Since I'm from Greece, my dad created fantastic yoghurt years ago, giving me insight into the making steps. The store-bought kinds are too factory-made for my liking, so I stay away from those. I like genuine old-school options instead, but I suspect you can't get them where you are.

NorthWillow72archive5d
↳ replying to @KeenThistle22

Kidding around about having brisket on hand. Greek meals really appeal to me, yet I feel lucky never to have tried the genuine article, otherwise the local versions might lose their appeal, and they taste fine as is.

GreyHarbour55archive5d

I really like the store's own yogurt. We purchase the large vanilla Greek kind and blend it together with granola. It tastes identical to the fancy brand. The supermarket version is okay as well.

SlowAlder33archive5d
↳ replying to @KeenThistle22

More details would be appreciated. I'd enjoy opinions from a true specialist.

AmberBeacon57archive5d
↳ replying to @KeenThistle22

I produce homemade yogurt from an entire gallon of A2 milk in each batch with my pressure cooker. The taste turns out excellent. Those four quarts cover my needs for nearly thirty days. The whole process feels straightforward since the components come out better and expenses drop.

KeenThistle22archive5d
↳ replying to @SlowAlder33

It's straightforward to produce your own yogurt and cheese if you start with quality ingredients. Plenty of online tutorials exist for the process. Store-bought versions often include additives to extend shelf life and improve appearance and consistency. In this area, superior options are available at comparable cost, so that's what we go for. Still, the majority around here stick with the processed kinds or even the sweetened varieties.

↳ replying to @NorthWillow72

There's a picture attached. I prepare far too much barbecue following the Texas approach with regional oak wood, basic salt plus pepper seasoning, and a gradual cook at low temperatures using an offset smoker.

RustLantern55archive5d
↳ replying to @KeenThistle22

At our place we prepare unprocessed high-fat yoghurt using the slow cooker. It's truly unique. My sibling owns several dairy animals. Unfortunately the children fail to enjoy this because they were raised on commercial Greek-style yoghurt. Those pointless added flavours have spoiled their sense of taste.

KeenThistle22archive5d
↳ replying to @RustLantern55

Yeah, I get what you mean. Too bad they aren't fans of the stuff. Owning my own dairy animals would be perfect. Someday once the kids are more grown.

GreyLantern71archive5d
↳ replying to @GreyHarbour55

Curious which granola varieties or makers others prefer.

GreyLantern71archive5d
↳ replying to @WarmSparrow60

That's a cool idea. It never crossed my mind to mix in walnuts or pecans until now.

WarmSparrow60archive5d
↳ replying to @GreyLantern71

I always grab the oversized packs at the warehouse retailer. They supply the crisp bite I'm after. Exactly like an ice cream sundae.

LevelTimber64archive5d
↳ replying to @NorthWillow72

Was that tasty brisket your own handiwork???

NorthWillow72archive5d
↳ replying to @LevelTimber64

Actually, ma'am, that was just me grabbing a photo. Chuckling here, I enjoy smoking brisket but I rarely bother since the whole process of getting it ready, cooking it low and slow, then letting it sit takes around fifteen hours. Still, you can't go far without running into a barbecue spot, with maybe half a dozen or so close by within ten miles.

LevelTimber64archive5d
↳ replying to @NorthWillow72

I felt thrilled believing you had prepared that dish. What a letdown... I never use a smoker for it. Season it first, then cook slowly over time before letting it sit. Excellent barbecue just doesn't exist in my current location. I long for it. Envious!

NorthWillow72archive5d
↳ replying to @LevelTimber64

Weekly I get the smoker started. Brisket counts as a bigger undertaking though. Chicken fish and steak show up often here. Ribs sausage and chicken receive frequent smoke sessions too. Pork butt with brisket appears during special events. A couple years ago turkeys were handled for myself and the neighbors.

KeenBeacon72archive5d

I grab their brand from the big retailer and stir oats into it. That wraps things up for me.

GreyHarbour55archive5d
↳ replying to @GreyLantern71

I discovered some excellent dark chocolate flavored with sea salt. There are sixteen grams of sugar in it, however we rarely consume sweets these days aside from festive occasions, so taking a spoonful seems worthwhile to me.

↳ replying to @KeenThistle22

I've been hunting around for your comments in this forum! There's no way to put into words just how much I long for that stuff while living over here in Germany.

LevelTimber64archive5d
↳ replying to @NorthWillow72

Whoa, this arrangement looks really impressive!!!

Related discussions

Add your experience

If you have tried it, this topic is still open. Sign in to reply — it takes a minute.