Notable they went with 9 mg rather than 8. Useful detail.
Appreciate you passing that along.
The thread covers trial outcomes showing strong average weight reduction over 68 weeks along with osteoarthritis relief, with doses up to 12 mg. Users note side effects like nausea and dysesthesia that increase at higher doses, and several describe the medication as preferable to bariatric procedures because effects are more reversible. Personal accounts include experiences switching from tirzepatide, maintenance after reaching goal, and observations about dropouts from rapid loss.
What this discussion establishesWhether excessive-loss dropouts were mainly psychological reactions from patients and families or tied to starting BMI and study length
Still openExact long-term maintenance strategies and full peer-reviewed details beyond the initial press reports
Nothing here is advice.
Appreciate you passing that along.
Notable they went with 9 mg rather than 8. Useful detail.
Outperforms weight loss surgery, glad this came through.
These drugs tend to have milder side effects overall, and most issues can be reversed unless something rare happens, unlike surgery.
The company announced up to 71 pounds average loss plus osteoarthritis relief in the first Phase 3 success. More specifics should come at a conference or in a paper. Retatrutide looks set to be a major new option, though several other weight loss drugs are likely to follow in the next few years.
Fewer people will need surgery. Some may still use the medication beforehand and possibly afterward. Surgery becomes less essential overall. Accounts of surgery patients show its side effects are typically harsher than those from these medications.
Appreciate the results post. One write-up highlights positives and negatives I missed, such as people leaving the study after losing too much weight and some notable side effects.
Surprising that 1.3 percent on placebo dropped more than 25 percent, and 4.8 percent of placebo users stopped because of side effects. The study ran 68 weeks.
Just left a subreddit thread that started on this topic but shifted into an argument about steroid users. Reddit can feel like an ADHD group sometimes.
These drugs are reducing the need for surgery. My own bypass years ago had manageable side effects, mainly the large loss itself. Surgeons might now combine the medications with procedures for very heavy patients, but I would skip surgery for typical obesity cases if these options had existed earlier.
I get the dysesthesia effect but the gains far outweigh it.
Many regain the weight or more after surgery. With this medication used properly there is room to adjust eating habits instead of being physically restricted.
I regained only about 100 pounds from my lowest point rather than everything. Tirzepatide has changed things for me and I am looking forward to trying retatrutide.
Sounds like the surgery worked out reasonably well for you with solid loss and no major complications, even if more reduction was still desired.
I reached about 55 percent of starting weight lost and came close to goal. That was better than average, though keeping it off has been the harder part. Clinical research interests me and I am eager for more retatrutide data, including the Phase 2 NEJM paper.
Gastric bypass and GLP-1 receptor agonists achieve weight loss through opposite mechanisms. Bypass physically limits intake and cuts vagus nerve signaling so the brain no longer receives direct stomach fullness cues via the GLP-1 route. The medications instead amplify that same pathway to its maximum.
That dropout pattern seems more psychological and social, with families reacting strongly to the sudden visible change in someone who had been heavy for years.
The program tests 2 mg, 4 mg, 6 mg, 9 mg, and 12 mg.
An open-access paper covers the trial design for obesity, sleep apnea, and knee osteoarthritis using basket methodology, which was new to me.
Dysesthesia jumps from 8.8 percent at 9 mg to 20.9 percent at 12 mg while other effects stay comparable to earlier drugs. The weight results and osteoarthritis benefit are striking.
I see something similar with my mother-in-law who has long been very heavy. She lists her health issues but hesitates on the medication despite knowing weight loss would help. Conversations stay careful because the topic is sensitive.
The basket design is clever for separating effects on weight, apnea, and osteoarthritis. Weight loss obviously eases knee pain, yet the setup tries to isolate the drug's direct impact.
I just got my first kit. Tirzepatide at 12.5 mg for nine weeks has stopped working well and sides are worsening, so this pushes me toward switching soon.
Would an oral version make it easier for her to start?
I see many gastric bypass patients with ongoing pain and complications that cannot be undone, though some do well and diabetes often improves. Still, medication seems preferable when possible.
She already uses injections for diabetes, but starting with research-grade material might not appeal to her.
These results are what I was waiting for. I reached goal on tirzepatide, have enough stocked for maintenance, and do not plan to switch. If starting fresh with more to lose, retatrutide would be the choice.
They were under medical supervision, so the full picture may need the published data.
The weight loss matched expectations from Phase 2 once the longer duration is considered. Side effects also tracked similarly. It is reassuring that the larger study confirmed the earlier strong findings.
One participant described quietly skipping doses after feeling too much weight had been lost.
Why not try the full 15 mg tirzepatide dose before switching, or was that ruled out by the side effects at 12.5 mg? I recently increased and noticed more sides after a smooth period at lower levels.
Dysesthesia involves spontaneous unpleasant sensations while allodynia is pain triggered by normally non-painful stimuli. They can overlap.
The trial ran 68 weeks with 445 people who had obesity and knee arthritis. Participants received either 9 mg or another dose of the drug.
An article discusses the dramatic weight loss seen in the next-generation trial.
That participant behavior concerns me for study integrity. Better verification of dosing would help, and skipping doses selfishly affects the data. It also hints that maintenance needs may be lower than peak trial doses.
These outcomes are what I was hoping to see. I have been holding material until the Phase 3 data arrived.
Sides became hard to manage past 7.5 mg, with very low calorie intake and returning food noise. The plateau started before any other additions. I may test the higher tirzepatide dose once more before deciding.
I would like access to that placebo for the extra knee pain reduction.
Hard to trust participants who waste the opportunity and break the agreement. They should face consequences.
ARA-290 has helped with allodynia in my experience and shows potential for dysesthesia and other nerve pain as well.
The allodynia is more of a minor annoyance now, especially with gym and snow shoveling discomfort. B vitamins help when I remember them.
Little extra loss between 9 mg and 12 mg suggests we are approaching the top effective dose.
It could also be the highest safe level. Going further might eliminate appetite entirely and lead to dangerous under-eating.
Growth hormone compounds increased my hunger and worked against the loss, so I paused them.
Thanks. The plateau predates the growth hormone addition. Scale movement is not the main concern, but lack of visible progress is worrying.
Trial entry required BMI of at least 27, and those who dropped for losing too much tended to start with lower BMI, which fits the longer study duration.
Helpful detail. I reached goal on retatrutide and am figuring out maintenance while trying to regain some muscle. Even with adjusted dosing and occasional higher intake I am still below maintenance calories.
Glad this forum exists. The same sensations appeared during another trial and staff dismissed them. It felt like a mix of both effects but mostly dysesthesia. Tirzepatide has not produced it so far.
When you say maxing out the signal, do you mean constant hunger or the opposite?
If you have tried it, this topic is still open. Sign in to reply — it takes a minute.